Divergent Views on Optimum Oil, Gas Staff Size in Malaysia
With cost reduction exerting continuous pressure on petroleum firms in the current industry downturn, companies have constantly grappled with the issue of an optimum workforce to sustain their oil and gas operations.
Recent news coverage about the industry highlighted this conundrum in Malaysia, where oil firm Royal Dutch Shell plc cut local staff as part of a move globally to rein in cost, while national oil company (NOC) Petroliam Nasional Berhad (PETRONAS) refrained from doing so despite facing similar headwinds due to other internal considerations.
As in other petroleum producing countries, the industry downturn in Malaysia has led to a loss of around 2,000 oil and gas jobs between January and July, or nearly 30 percent of the 6,547 being laid off in the country, local daily The Star reported Sept. 26. Workers in the industry remain vulnerable to layoffs as major petroleum firms in Malaysia could include them as part of any global job cuts if oil prices do not recover.
Vitol Group, the world’s largest oil trader, believed that it was unlikely for crude oil to trade above $60 a barrel in 2016 as the effects of slowing global demand growth could be exacerbated by a return of Iranian and possibly Libyan supplies, Reuters reported Oct. 20. Global benchmark Brent crude futures and U.S. oil futures have lost more than 50 percent of their value since falling from the psychologically important $100 a barrel mark in the second half of last year.
Shell Malaysia Downsizes Workforce
Shell’s local unit, Shell Malaysia announced Sept. 29 plans to cut around 1,300 positions from its upstream division over the next two years, representing approximately 20 percent of the 6,500 staff that it currently employs. The oil major had indicated July 30 that it would reduce its workforce by 6,500 this year as part of its goal to trim operating costs by 10 percent.
“This is certainly a very difficult decision to make. We have made adjustments in our upstream portfolio and we will drive greater efficiency in our operations. Regretfully, these have resulted in an unavoidable impact on staff,” Shell Malaysia Chairman Iain Lo said in the Sept. 29 press release.
With a focus on the current low oil price environment, Lo said “continuing business as usual is not sustainable,” adding that “we are strengthening our organization by prioritizing productivity and efficiency, without compromising on safety and reliability. We will emerge from this process as a more nimble, resilient and competitive player in the Malaysian oil and gas industry.”
PETRONAS Not Rightsizing, Staff Redeployed to RAPID
As one of the largest oil producer in Southeast Asia, PETRONAS has also been adversely affected by the 50 percent decline in global crude prices over the past year. Still, the firm – which employs around 51,000 staff as indicated in PETRONAS Sustainability Report 2014 – has not retrenched workers.
“We are fortunate that with the coming onstream of new projects, we are able to redeploy staff – for example, many of the workforce in the upstream divisions have been redeployed to the RAPID project. If there is no RAPID, then we may come to a situation where we will have to rightsize the organization,” PETRONAS President and CEO Wan Zulkiflee Wan Ariffin said in an Oct. 12 interview with Malaysian daily The New Strait Times.
He was referring to the construction of a $16 billion Refinery and Petrochemical Integrated Development (RAPID) project at the Pengerang Integrated Complex (PIC) in southern Johor, Malaysia after the NOC approved the final investment decision in April 2014. The PIC will consist of a refinery equipped to process 300,000 barrels per day of crude oil and a petrochemical complex with a production capacity of 7.7 million tons per annum. RAPID is slated to start-up operations in early 2019.
In fact, the downturn in the oil and gas market has not led to a hiring freeze at PETRONAS, with the company still on the look-out for staff, albeit at a gradual pace.
“There is no freeze in hiring. I do not want to freeze hiring. We had some experience in the past where we stopped hiring but later felt the impact some years later. The hiring will continue but maybe at a slower pace. We still need to bring in new people. We have not come to a point where we have to rightsize,” Wan Zulkiflee explained.
Layoffs Not Necessarily Cost-Effective
While the issue of what constitutes an optimum staff size depends on the needs of individual companies, some market players pointed out at “The HR & Recruitment Roundtable Summit” in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia Sept. 30 to Oct. 1 that firms should only resort to downsizing or rightsizing as a last resort.
“Layoffs should be your last resort, not your first resort because once you lay them off, they are not going to come back to you,” Sharmini Ann Jacob, KPMG’s director of People & Change, and management consulting ASEAN, told participants at the event.
As layoffs during an industry downturn could potentially include a skilled or talented staff, such action could be detrimental to the company’s longer term interests.
“In an economic downturn, talent becomes even more crucial in the organization because you want to keep them in and not have them scare and running to your competitor or running to a different industry altogether,” Sharmini commented.
She added that “when they [staff] leave, not only you have to rehire but you then have to retrain and you have a whole lot of delays [to your projects] because of that.”
Such views resonated with another speaker at the KL event, who pointed that staff layoffs is not a viable solution given the long term manpower needs of the industry. Redeployment of staff as in the case of PETRONAS could be an option.
“There will be an upturn ... and we don't want to scramble to hire again. We [will] try to ride out the storm,” the speaker noted, adding that “studies have tracked the performances of downsizing firms versus non-downsizing firms for as long as 9 years after a downsizing event. And the findings as a group, the downsizers never outperform the non-downsizers.”
Talent Management Still Key in Current Market
Even in the worst industry downturn in nearly a decade, talent management remains a top item in the agenda for oil and gas companies.
“The world is becoming smaller and we need to look after our talent a lot better. And when I say talent, it’s not the top 5 percent or the top 10 percent, it’s the entire organization,” Sharmini said.
“Whether there is a business turnaround [upwards or downwards], talent risk, cost optimization, demographics, deal situations … Talent is an issue and you need to think about it.”
In fact, CEO Wan Zulkiflee told the New Strait Times Oct. 12 that talent management is one of the six focus areas for PETRONAS over the next few years. The others are cash generation; delivery on growth projects – RAPID, floating liquefied natural gas (FLNG) and Canadian LNG projects; lowering costs and simplifying processes; investing in technology; and work culture.
“Last year, we spent $115.9 million (MYR 500 million) on talent management. I want to be sure that every [Malaysian] ringgit we spend on talent management is well spent. We are not cutting back on talent management spending, but we must make sure that we spend in areas that we really need to spend. We are looking at how we can do this better,” he commented.
“This is to ensure that there are enough leaders in the pipeline for succession planning and to drive the business forward … we are continuing with talent development even in these tough times.”
Commenting on the change in demographics of staff working in PETRONAS, where 55 percent of employees are below the age of 35, the CEO said that the company’s management has got to be more engaging.
“With the company now having more people of the younger generation ... management style has got to change. I feel there are a lot of untapped potentials in this company. If we can unleash this potential, we can do a lot more things,” Wan Zulkiflee told the New Strait Times.
PETRONAS is not only trying to tailor its management style in keeping with a younger staff profile, but the company is also enhancing its appeal among existing and potential female employees.
“We … take note now of the number of females in the organization. We got our first lady drilling supervisor and … we have mothers’ rooms, many of which we converted from smoking rooms. We also allow three months’ maternity leave. These are to attract the female gender because there are more female graduates now. These are the kind of things that will make the company attractive.”