OPEC+ Attempting to Train Traders to Not Fight Its Decisions
Bond traders have painfully learned not to fight the Fed - now, OPEC+ is attempting to train oil traders not to fight its decisions.
That’s what BofA Global Research analysts stated in a new report sent to Rigzone, which highlighted that Brent crude oil prices had dropped from a high point of $139 per barrel in the first half of 2022 to a low point of $70 per barrel in the first half of 2023, “prompting the ‘central bank’ of oil, OPEC+, to withdraw 1.66 million barrels from the market in a surprise move”.
In the report, the analysts said that, with this “novel approach”, OPEC+ expects to offset oil demand risks from the banking crisis and discourage macro speculation against oil markets.
“Put differently, the group is determined to preserve the value of crude even in a recession, particularly against a backdrop of high inflation - and it does not want to wait for oil prices to drop below $50 per barrel to make a supply cut decision, as it may have in the past,” the BofA Global Research analysts noted in the report.
Looking at whether or not OPEC+’s strategy will work, BofA Global Research analysts stated in the report “we think so”.
“For starters, macro indicators do not suggest an imminent slowdown and price sensitive services-driven demand (jet fuel and gasoline) should be supported by China’s re-opening and strong Western labor markets, while industrial-linked demand (naphtha, gasoil, fuel oil), which is already weak, seems less likely to get hit by higher oil prices,” the analysts said.
“So, OPEC+ already has a strong tailwind to work with. Importantly, in a world of scarce physical supplies and ample consumer demand, the price elasticity of U.S. shale production has dropped sharply, placing OPEC+ again at the center of oil price formation,” the analysts added.
“While the U.S. may not be refilling the Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR), OPEC+ will now move to push down commercial oil stocks. Meanwhile, geopolitics are aligning incentives for OPEC+ members to work together. But it may now prove harder to enforce an EU/U.S. cap on Russian oil, as Japan’s energy policies are already showing,” the analysts continued.
Pricing Implications
The BofA Global Research analysts highlighted in the report that, in their view, there are “three key pricing implications from the OPEC+ cuts”.
“First, Brent prices will likely average $10-$15 per barrel above prior forwards of $81 per barrel over the next 12 months,” the analysts said in the report.
“Second, the term structure of oil will likely stay in sticky backwardation. Third, crude spreads will likely narrow, hurting global refining margins and transferring value back to producers,” the analysts added.
“Previously, we expected a small 200,000 barrel per day oil market surplus in 2023, but now see a 400,000 barrel per day deficit post cuts and banking crunch,” the analysts continued.
With inventories now poised to drop, Brent volatility should decline, helping anchor oil price expectations, the analysts stated in the BofA Global Research report.
“Yet physical OPEC+ crude oil cuts will clash with monetary central bank hikes designed to rein in demand, posing macro risks. Net, we stay constructive and still see $88 per barrel average Brent in 2023,” the analysts said in the report.
According to an extraordinary market update by Rystad Energy Senior Vice President Jorge Leon, which was sent to Rigzone earlier this month, if fully delivered, the newly announced OPEC+ cuts would further tighten an already fundamentally tight oil market, drive Brent towards $100 per barrel sooner than previously expected and push the price to around $110 per barrel this summer.
“Rystad Energy believes that these voluntary cuts will further tighten the oil market for the rest of the year and could push prices above $100 per barrel and keep them above that level for most of the rest of the year,” Leon said in the update.
Strong Signal
In a statement commenting on the OPEC+ cut sent to Rigzone last week, RANE Senior Global Analyst Matthew Bey said, “Saudi Arabia and its allies are believed to have wanted to target speculators who had been betting on a decline in oil prices in the wake of the SVB collapse and Credit Suisse takeover”.
“It sends a strong signal from OPEC+ to the market that the bloc will act if oil prices fall below $75 or $80 per barrel for an extended period of time,” Bey added in the statement.
“Saudi Arabia and OPEC+ are betting that any price increase does not result in boosting upstream investment into shale oil and the United States. Cost inflation and crew shortages are likely to continue to constrain U.S. shale oil production’s sensitivity to price increases,” he noted.
In the statement, Bey highlighted that Saudi Arabia and several other OPEC+ countries’ decision to cut oil production drove an increase in oil prices last week “as the move was unexpected and markets had not priced in such a cut”.
A report sent to Rigzone by Standard Chartered earlier this month revealed that analysts at the company thought the decisive factor behind the cut was “positioning data” and “the rapid move towards a bearish speculative extreme amid the market turmoil that followed the collapse of SVB”. The report noted that there was 228.9 million barrels of speculative net selling of crude oil in just two weeks and highlighted that this was a faster selling rate than at the start of pandemic lockdowns.
To contact the author, email andreas.exarheas@rigzone.com
What do you think? We’d love to hear from you, join the conversation on the
Rigzone Energy Network.
The Rigzone Energy Network is a new social experience created for you and all energy professionals to Speak Up about our industry, share knowledge, connect with peers and industry insiders and engage in a professional community that will empower your career in energy.