Tough Times Force OPEC Members to Close Ranks
CAIRO (AFP), Dec. 7, 2009
Divisions within OPEC have eased as the dual threat of the global economic crisis and climate change talks force oil producers to be pragmatic and unified, analysts said on Sunday.
Two years ago, when oil prices soared to nearly 100 dollars a barrel, the oil exporters cartel, which includes both allies and foes of the United States, was severely tested.
The Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries was then torn between price hawks like Algeria, Iran, Libya and Venezuela on one side and nations like Saudi Arabia which wanted moderate prices in the interests of consumers.
But the stance of the price hawks has since lost support, leading to a convergence of positions within the bloc.
Less than three weeks ahead of the next OPEC meeting in Luanda, Angola, the group's oil ministers agree that quotas must remain at their current level of 24.84 million barrels per day (bpd).
Even U.S. arch-foes Iran and Venezuela support that view.
Although the price of oil is trading at around 75 dollars a barrel, nobody is daring to ask for 100 dollars.
Observers say this unity has come about largely thanks to pragmatism instilled into producers by the events of 2008: an unprecedented price surge to 147.50 dollars a barrel, followed by a plunge to 32.40 dollars in December.
"What happened makes you think. An oil price of 75 dollars is higher than they could have hoped for. Even the most hawkish nations are finding it hard to ask for more," said Francis Perrin of the Oil and Gas Journal.
This turnaround came about because producers were afraid of another price collapse, according to Julian Lee, analyst at the Centre For Global Energy Studies in London.
"They still have a big fear of oil (prices) falling ... They haven't entirely lost that fear," said Lee.
Another reason for the appeasement of the hawks was that the countries which traditionally call for high prices have proved less than effective in implementing decisions taken by OPEC.
At a meeting in Oran, Algeria in December 2008, OPEC pledged to withdraw 4.2 million bpd from production from the start of 2009 in order to stabilise the market.
However, the bulk of the sacrifice was provided by Saudi Arabia, while Iran didn't implement the agreed cut in production.
"The influence of the hawks is limited" because "if somebody raises the issue of higher prices ... he will be told to comply more," said David Wech, an analyst at JBC Energy.
Finally, while the impact of the global recession is still being felt on oil demand, another key challenge for producers looms in the shape of measures to reduce carbon emissions.
Such a deal could be signed this week in Copenhagen during landmark UN-led talks on tackling global warming.
"When you see in the OPEC bulletins the rising concern linked to climate change, you can see that producers are closing ranks," said Perrin. "In the hardest times in its history, OPEC tends to stick together."
Copyright (c) 2009 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
- OPEC's Cheer Over 2018 Oil Rally Tinged By Shale Worries (Jan 09)
- OPEC's Oil Cuts Claim a Victim as Supertanker Earnings Crash (Jan 09)
- BLOG: What do Rigzone Readers Think of the OPEC/NOPEC Deal? (Dec 07)