Texas City Bans Fracking In Its Birthplace, Court Battles Loom


DALLAS, Nov 5 (Reuters) - Voters approved a ban on hydraulic fracturing in the north Texas town of Denton on Tuesday, making it the first city in the Lone Star State to outlaw the oil and gas extraction technique behind the U.S. energy boom.

The vote in the city of 123,000 was highly symbolic because hydraulic fracturing, better known as fracking, is widely used in Texas, the top crude producer in the United States.

Green groups said the result served as a wake-up call to the industry, but several similar measures failed in cities and counties in Ohio and California.

The Texas Oil & Gas Association, the state's energy lobby, on Wednesday quickly filed for an injunction.

"A ban on hydraulic fracturing is inconsistent with state law," Thomas Phillips, a former head of the Supreme Court of Texas who now represents the trade group, said.

Texas Railroad Commissioner David Porter, the state's top energy regulator, called for the prohibition to be tossed out.

"Bans based on misinformation - instead of science and fact - potentially threaten this energy renaissance and as a result, the well-being of all Texans," he said.

In a frack job, a mix of pressurized water, sand and chemicals is used to unlock hydrocarbons from rock. Operators say it is safe but many environmental groups oppose the practice - calling it wasteful, polluting, dirty and noisy.

"Denton, Texas is where hydraulic fracturing was invented," said Bruce Baizel, Earthworks energy program director. "If this place in the heart of the oil and gas industry can't live with fracking, then who can?"

Fracking was pioneered at the Barnett shale formation where Denton is located. Exxon Mobil's XTO unit honed its shale expertise in the natural gas-rich Barnett. Most of the crude output in Texas comes, however, from the growing Eagle Ford and Permian fields to the south and west.

The Denton referendum pitted oil and gas operators and mineral rights owners against residents who say their homes and lives are being encroached on by work that can be noisy, soak up scarce water supplies and overwhelm roads with heavy truck traffic.

The Denton measure won more than 58 percent of the 25,376 ballots cast, official results showed.

Elsewhere, the Ohio cities of Gates Mills, Kent and Youngstown rejected proposed fracking bans, while Athens approved one. In California, proposed fracking bans failed in Santa Barbara County but passed in Mendocino and San Benito counties, official results and local media reports said.

The votes are not expected to have any meaningful impact on U.S. crude output, which has soared to a 25-year high.

The local votes in Ohio and California, two among a dozen or so states that have clear rules allowing fracking, were held to directly challenge the states' authority over the issue.

Some Colorado towns have previously tried to prohibit fracking, only to run into lawsuits.

There are about 270 wells in Denton, about 30 miles (50 km) north of Dallas and home to two state universities.

"It's essentially a ban on all drilling," said Ed Ireland, executive director of the Barnett Shale Energy Education Council, a group aligned with producers. "No one would try to drill a well if they can't frack it."

Groups like Frack Free Denton won even though they were outspent by a margin of 10 to one, according to organizers and local media reports.

(Reporting By Terry Wade; Editing by Chizu Nomiyama, Steve Orlofsky and Cynthia Osterman)


Generated by readers, the comments included herein do not reflect the views and opinions of Rigzone. All comments are subject to editorial review. Off-topic, inappropriate or insulting comments will be removed.

Bill Cagle  |  November 06, 2014
The comment about hydraulic fracturing being invented in the Denton, TX area is historically highly inaccurate. Hydraulic fracturing was invented by Stanolind Oil & Gas in Tulsa, OK in the late 1940s. Stanolind later became Amoco, which was purchased by BP. U.S. Patents were filed by Stanolind in 1948 and issued in 1952 (Farris & Clark). Two fracturing specialists (Carl T. Montgomery & Michael B. Smith) estimated that there have been close to 2.5 million fracture treatments performed worldwide since Stanolind Oil introduced hydraulic fracturing in 1949. So hydraulic fracturing was not invented in Denton, TX, is not new, and is over six decades old. What is new is drilling horizontally for several thousand feet and doing multiple hydraulic fracturing treatments. This was first accomplished in the Barnett Shale in the Ft. Worth, TX (Denton, TX) area by George Mitchell/Mitchell Energy.
R. Mark Conger  |  November 06, 2014
It boils down to the same problem northerners have with fracking. If they dont have the mineral rights, and dont have any skin in the game, then they want it stopped for selfish reasons. It has nothing to do with science or environmental protection. If these people held the mineral rights, theyd be cheering on more drilling and fracking. Its all about the money, as usual, somebody that feels left out and they want their perceived share.