Asian Demand Response Key To Balancing Global Gas Market
Europe’s efforts to wean itself off Russian gas have left the region searching for ways to plug the gap. As a result, demand for LNG in Europe soared and turned the global market on its head, Wood Mackenzie said.
Traditionally, when global LNG demand exceeds supply, Europe would act as the balance by bringing in more Russian pipeline gas. But now, with limited pipeline imports, Europe is competing with Asia for LNG. And Asia has become the balance market.
Trade flows have shifted radically with Europe, now the premium market, effectively pulling supply away from Asia. This increased competition, coupled with soaring LNG spot prices and Covid lockdowns, has caused Asian LNG imports to fall by 7 percent year-to-date. The most severe drops have been seen in China (-20%), India (-18%), Pakistan (-14%), and Bangladesh (-13%).
How do high prices impact Asia LNG demand?
Asian buyers have been at the forefront of high spot prices – in some cases driving up prices to new summer peaks, even after the run-up in prices started earlier this year.
Uncontracted spot demand in Asia is typically most at risk for demand destruction, as are consumers with weaker purchasing power. The regional gas landscape is comprised of diverse markets, sectors, and buyers, with varying spot exposure, purchasing power and downstream market regulation and pricing. And many Asian buyers, despite affordability concerns, have continued spot buying at record high prices this year.
Buyers in legacy markets purchase most of their LNG on long-term contracts, which are typically indexed to oil. This helps to insulate markets and buyers from high LNG spot prices and on a weighted average cost basis, Asian markets are less exposed than Europe.
Asia’s spending on energy imports has already increased exponentially in 2022 as governments seek to avoid critical ‘light on – lights off’ decisions. In emerging Asia in particular, this has led to soaring gas and electricity prices, rising subsidy bills, rolling power blackouts, and curtailments to industrial users. In extreme cases, skyrocketing LNG import costs have exacerbated political and social unrest in countries like Pakistan and Bangladesh.
Which markets are most vulnerable to demand response, and why?
Drivers are ultimately unique to each market. But when assessing demand response in Asia so far this year, two key determinants stand out: the level of LNG spot exposure and the availability of alternative fuels, including other non-LNG gas supplies.
High spot exposure and high availability of alternative fuels increases the likelihood of demand response. This characterizes markets like China and India which have seen the largest reductions to date as consumers switch to coal and fuel oil in power and non-power sectors. Bangladesh, Pakistan, and Thailand have limited options for fuel switching. As a result, LNG spot buying must continue to avoid blackouts and demand destruction.
At the other extreme are markets with low spot exposure and limited fuel switching alternatives, like Singapore, Japan, and South Korea. These markets are slower to respond, insulated by their contract position and strong purchasing power. Net exporters, Malaysia, and Indonesia are similarly cushioned from demand response risks.
Where is fuel switching likely?
Traditionally, coal has been a cheaper alternative to gas in Northeast Asian power sectors. But switching from gas to coal has been limited so far this year. Pro-gas policies have meant that countries have not been incentivized to make the change. And with record-high coal prices this year, switching may not significantly reduce import bills.
In South Asia, oil is the primary substitute for gas in key sectors. India has reduced LNG usage by 30 to 40% year-on-year in refineries and petrochemical plants. Large-scale industries have replaced LNG with domestic gas, produced in India’s eastern offshore. And other small industries are switching to fuel oil and liquefied petroleum gas for heating. Replacing captive power generation with coal-dominated grid-based power has also offered some savings.
Elsewhere, high-sulfur fuel oil (HSFO) has been the fuel of choice. Oil-fired power generation has surged five-fold in Pakistan and 45% in Bangladesh to date. Pakistan’s demand for LNG continues to trend above 2020 levels, but this is likely unsustainable. In contrast, Bangladesh has put a halt on expensive spot LNG imports since July. Both markets are already facing regular blackouts. Demand-side management measures are being implemented but the situation is likely to worsen.
As prices soften post-2026, many markets that are cutting their LNG demand today are expected to rebound. How quickly and to what extent Asia demand rebounds, though, is highly dependent on price levels and government policy towards coal.
To contact the author, email email@example.com
WHAT DO YOU THINK?
Generated by readers, the comments included herein do not reflect the views and opinions of Rigzone. All comments are subject to editorial review. Off-topic, inappropriate or insulting comments will be removed.
Editor | Rigzone