Evercore: Super Majors Ripe for Consolidation and Other Restructuring
Despite their relative safety during the downturn, large integrated oil companies must make some moves to get higher returns and more investor support, analysts at Evercore ISI said in a Nov. 13 webinar that covered a wealth of industry concerns.
Doug Terreson, senior managing director and head of energy research, said that during the last merger phase, which started in 1998, companies were focused on returns at the expense of growth. That lasted until 2008, when their capital spending per shareholder distributions increased and then returns declined.
“Both internal and external initiatives are available to the management teams of the super majors, which would enhance their profile with investors in the equity market,” he said.
He noted that ConocoPhillips in 2009 and early 2010 recognized this and began an internal “clear the decks” restructuring of selling off assets, which led to higher returns, high valuations and better performance in the stock market.
“The only hesitancy we have with this option is, this company was selling assets when oil prices were near $100 per barrel. Today, Brent is closer to $50 per barrel and returns aren’t going to be as strong this time around to get the bang for the buck that other companies received through restructuring in years past,” he said.
The other option for the majors and super majors is consolidation, he said. More cash flow is being devoted to paying off debt than the market has seen since 1999, making conditions right for consolidation in the exploration and production (E&P) space. However, management needs their investors’ support for such transactions, and that might be difficult for some to come by.
During the last five years, the average E&P paid itself about $40 million annually while annuals returns for shareholders compounded at 2 percent.
“We think if transactions end up being hostile, these companies are going to have a hard time garnering support from shareholders when considering what appears to be a pay and performance disconnect,” he said, adding that when considering significant underperformance by U.S. integrated oil and E&P entities, “We question the defense of management teams and business models that obviously have not served shareholders very well.”
Still, the approach would serve both shareholders and management well. With consolidation, debt is restructured with more favorable terms. Combined, these companies typically spend about two-thirds of what they would spend as separate entities, Torreson said. Consequently, they are able to enhance the value of their purchases, he said.
If the 12 largest E&Ps consolidated into six companies, it would consolidate two-thirds of the three largest shale basins in North America.
“With the growth in U.S. shale oil supply during the last few years and the U.S. contribution to global oil supply growth in the last several years … [consolidation] result in more measured spending. More measured future growth in non-OPEC supply would follow because capital and resources would be concentrated in fewer, more disciplined hands,” he explained.
Winners And “Others”
Senior managing director at Evercore, Stephen Richardson, said there will be a significant bifurcation between those companies that emerge stronger from the downturn and those that don’t. E&P companies will begin to climb out first, he said, and Evercore expects a rebalancing in 2016.
That bifurcation won’t necessarily be a bad thing, said James West, senior managing director of the oilfield services group.
“These conditions will ultimately cleanse the oil patch and will set the stage for a sustained upcycle, with large-cap diversifieds being the primary beneficiary of a gain in market share and pricing power,” he said. “Large public companies stand to benefit from shrinking environment as smaller, private companies go out of business. A third of the commodity providers of service in North America are basically going to go away in this down cycle.”
12
View Full Article
WHAT DO YOU THINK?
Generated by readers, the comments included herein do not reflect the views and opinions of Rigzone. All comments are subject to editorial review. Off-topic, inappropriate or insulting comments will be removed.
- The Rigzone Interview: Private Equity Cash Focuses on Oil, Gas Development
- Could Argentinian Politics Beat the Vaca Muerta?
- The Rigzone Interview: Oil, Gas Goes Digital for Safety, Speed
- Deal Of The Month: EQT, Rice Energy Merge in Mega Marcellus $6.7B Gas Deal
- OpEd: OPEC Production Cuts Fail, Markets Pay for Underestimating US Shale
- ExxonMobil Racks Up Discoveries in Guyana Block Eyed by Chevron
- Oil Market Sentiment Has Improved Significantly
- EU, US Eye Collaboration on Nuclear Materials
- USA Driving Activity to Increase to All-Time Highs
- EU Electricity Export to Ukraine Up 94 Percent in Two Years
- China Coal Output Falls for First Time since Government Ordered More
- TC Energy to Sell Prince Rupert Gas Pipeline Project to First Nation
- BP Pulse Buys One of Europe's Largest Truck Stops
- UK CCUS Plans Outdated: Think Tank
- I Squared Eyes Full Ownership of Europe Gas Storage Firm
- Norway Regulator Blasts Proposal to Halt New Oil and Gas Permits
- Chinese Mega Company Makes Major Oilfield Discovery
- EIA Drops 2024 Henry Hub Gas Price Forecast
- EIA and Standard Chartered Offer Up Latest Oil Price Predictions
- Red Sea Region Sees Another Watershed Incident
- Chevron Oil Project in Kazakhstan to Cost $48.5B
- OPEC Voices Encouragement after IEA Affirms Support for Oil Security
- Biden Govt Bares Strategy for Freight Charging, Hydrogen Fueling Infra
- Ukraine Hits Third Russian Refinery In Escalating Drone Strikes
- Rystad Looks at the Buzz Around White Hydrogen
- VIDEO: Missile Attack Kills Crew Transiting Gulf of Aden
- Norway Regulator Blasts Proposal to Halt New Oil and Gas Permits
- Chinese Mega Company Makes Major Oilfield Discovery
- What Is the Biggest Risk to Offshore Oil and Gas Personnel in 2024?
- Is Peak Oil Demand Close?
- Vessel Sinks in Red Sea After Missile Strike
- JP Morgan, Standard Chartered Reveal Latest Oil Price Forecasts
- Exxon Rights in Stabroek Do Not Apply to Hess Merger with Chevron: Hess
- Rystad Forecasts Net Production of Top Permian Producers in 2024
- Analysts Reveal Latest Oil Price Outlook Following OPEC+ Cut Extension