Ex-BP Supervisors Win Dismissal of Some Manslaughter Charges

Deepwater Horizon Gulf of Mexico Oil Spill


Dec 10 (Reuters) - Two former BP Plc supervisors won the dismissal on Tuesday of some of the manslaughter charges facing them over the Gulf of Mexico drilling rig explosion that killed 11 people in 2010.

U.S. District Judge Stanwood Duval in New Orleans dismissed 11 counts of seaman's manslaughter facing Deepwater Horizon rig well site leaders Robert Kaluza and Donald Vidrine.

But the judge refused to dismiss 11 other counts of involuntary manslaughter, leaving those and a Clean Water Act violation charge to be heard at a trial starting in June.

David Gerger, a lawyer for Kaluza, said he was reviewing the decision.

A lawyer for Vidrine and representatives for the U.S. Justice Department did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Kaluza and Vidrine were the two highest-ranking supervisors on board the Deepwater Horizon when disaster struck on April 20, 2010, sending millions of barrels of oil into the Gulf of Mexico.

The indictment accused the men of "negligent and grossly negligent" supervision of testing at the well in the run up to the explosion.

The charges were announced on Nov. 15 last year, the same day BP agreed to pay $4 billion and plead guilty 14 criminal counts over conduct leading up to and after the disaster.

A trial is currently underway in the case of another employee, former BP engineer Kurt Mix, who is accused of deleting records related to the estimated size of the spill. He denies wrongdoing.

In his ruling on Tuesday, Duval rejected the arguments by lawyers for Kaluza and Vidrine that the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act did not extend federal law to the outer continental shelf, where Deepwater Horizon was located.

But the judge accepted the defendants' arguments that the seaman's manslaughter charges did not extend to them as oil well site leaders with no navigation function on the Deepwater Horizon.

Duval said his ruling was the first in the statute's 175-year history to apply the law to a drilling rig blow-out, and he acknowledged the "risk of explosion on board deepwater drilling facilities is a grave matter.

But Duval said he "refuses to expand the scope of the statute unnecessarily without certainty as to Congress' intent to do so."

The case is U.S. v. Kaluza, U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Louisiana, No. 12-cr-00265.

Copyright 2017 Thomson Reuters. Click for Restrictions.


Click on the button below to add a comment.
Post a Comment
Generated by readers, the comments included herein do not reflect the views and opinions of Rigzone. All comments are subject to editorial review. Off-topic, inappropriate or insulting comments will be removed.
Jack Nelson | Dec. 15, 2013
Having worked more than 40 year in the offshore industry, close to 30 years as a senior supervisor on board, then a Rig Manager, in different places in the world, BP, and TransOcean are to blame for what happened. I have attended many of those morning meetings. I have also had telephone calls from the Captain and Rig Superintendent about 3 minutes after some of those meetings, when the Oil Company Rep wanted to just do whatever to save time and money. There were no comments about "oh, well, thats what we have the big pincsers for". That person would not have lasted very long as an employee. Yes, I told them to shut it down, I would get back to them. Yes, I called my supervisor, and my contact at the oil company. We had a meeting, and settled things. Then I called the Supervisors on board and gave them the go ahead, with some details changed. No spill, nobody died.

mark bexon | Dec. 11, 2013
I think that if the Federal Government had taken the same attitude towards responsibility for an individuals negligence to the Snr managers of Bank of America, Leman Bros. AIG and others the world would be in far better shape today….

Related Companies

Our Privacy Pledge

Deepwater Horizon Images
Discoverer Enterprise Macondo BOP Stack ROV Accessing Horizon BOP Panel Oil Spill Aerial View
Development Driller III Deepwater Horizon in Flames (Apr 20) Diagram & Photos of Horizon Riser / Pipe Crewmen aboard the motor vessel
71 more images view image library

From the Career Center
Jobs that may interest you
HSE Area Manager, CO
Expertise: Environmental, Safety & Training|HSE Manager / Advisor|Safety Training Rep
Location: 80645
Logistics Coordinator
Expertise: Dispatcher|Logistics Management
Location: Tomball, TX
Compliance Technician
Expertise: Production Operator|Regulatory Compliance
Location: Louisiana, United States, LA
search for more jobs

Brent Crude Oil : $56.43/BBL 0.40%
Light Crude Oil : $50.55/BBL 0.27%
Natural Gas : $2.95/MMBtu 5.44%
Updated in last 24 hours