Study Finds Higher Earthquake Risk from Wastewater Injecting than Fracking

Study Finds Higher Earthquake Risk from Wastewater Injecting than Fracking

Underground injection of wastewater produced by hydraulic fracturing and other energy technologies poses a higher risk of causing earthquakes that can be felt by people than the hydraulic fracturing process itself, according to a recent study by the National Research Council.

Carbon capture and storage (CCS) could potentially cause seismic events because significant volumes of fluids are injected underground over long periods of time. But because no large-scale projects are in operation, not enough information exists to understand the potential for these projects to cause earthquakes, according to the committee that wrote the report.

The study, sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy, examines the potential for technologies involved in shale gas recovery, carbon capture and storage (CCS), geothermal energy production and conventional oil and gas development, to cause earthquakes.

The total balance of fluid introduced or removed underground was found to be the factor most directly correlated with induced earthquakes, the committee said. Because CCS and geothermal energy each involve net fluid injection or withdrawal, all could potentially cause earthquakes felt by people.

However, technologies designed to maintain a balance between the amounts of fluids injected and withdrawn, such as most geothermal and conventional oil and gas development, appear to produce fewer-induced seismic events than technologies that do not maintain fluid balance.

Hydraulic fracturing, which involves injecting a mix of water, sand and chemicals in short bursts at high pressure into deep underground wells, cracks the shale formation and allows gas to escape and flow up the well with wastewater. Injecting this water underground is one way in which wastewater is discarded.

"Although induced seismic events associated with these energy technologies have not resulted in loss of life or significant damage in the United States, some effects have been felt by local residents and have raised concern about additional seismic activity and its consequences in areas where energy development is ongoing or planned," the committee said.

While scientists understand the general mechanisms that cause seismic events, they cannot accurately predict the magnitude or occurrence of these earthquakes due to insufficient information about natural rock systems and lack of validated predictive models at specific energy development sites.

Debate has ensued in recent months as to whether shale gas exploration activity causes earthquake activity.

Earlier this year, the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) issued new standards for the transportation and disposal of brine, a by-product of hydraulic fracturing after an investigation of geological information and well activity data indicated that a number of earthquakes in the Youngstown, Ohio area had been induced.

While geologists believe induced seismic activity is extremely rare, it can occur with the confluence of a series of specific circumstances, ODNR officials said.

Karen Boman has more than 10 years of experience covering the upstream oil and gas sector. Email Karen at


Click on the button below to add a comment.
Post a Comment
Generated by readers, the comments included herein do not reflect the views and opinions of Rigzone. All comments are subject to editorial review. Off-topic, inappropriate or insulting comments will be removed.
randy | Jun. 18, 2012
The industry needs to be proactive about this. Various environmental groups will seize on this and if not kept in proper context, this can quickly get out of hand...

Tom | Jun. 15, 2012
The more Americans keep coming up with reasons to not produce oil and gas will keep the price high and dependence on oil from countries that do not like America. This will also cut job in the US sector. Cut tax revenue to states. This will also lead to cut by states in education. Its ok to give trillions of dollars to the banks. All they did was give the money away in bonuses to them selves. At least the O&G sector creates jobs and pays taxes.


Our Privacy Pledge

Most Popular Articles

From the Career Center
Jobs that may interest you
Project Controls Specialist
Expertise: Project Management
Location: Minneapolis
Business Development Manager
Expertise: Business Development|Construction Manager|Sales
Location: West Sacramento, CA
Business Development Manager
Expertise: Business Development|Construction Manager|Sales
Location: Denver, CO
search for more jobs

Brent Crude Oil : $50.79/BBL 1.30%
Light Crude Oil : $49.96/BBL 1.10%
Natural Gas : $2.77/MMBtu 2.12%
Updated in last 24 hours