Travel Restrictions Eased on BP Engineer Mix

Deepwater Horizon Gulf of Mexico Oil Spill

Travel Restrictions Eased on BP Engineer Mix

U.S. Magistrate Judge Daniel Knowles agreed to ease travel restrictions on Kurt Mix, who was charged with destroying evidence sought in the investigation of the Deepwater Horizon oil spill, Bloomberg reported Friday.

Mix had asked the judge to ease the travel restrictions placed on him as a condition of bail. Mix is now allowed to travel within Texas and to Louisiana, Massachusetts and New York, but must get a judge's permission to travel outside these states.

The former BP engineer has been charged with two felony counts of obstruction of justice. The indictment alleges that Mix sought to block the United States government's grand jury investigation by deleting from his iPhone two text messages strings containing information about the Macondo well's flow rate and BP's efforts to halt the flow of oil from the well.

The government cited one particular message in its indictment. In that message, dated May 26, 2010, Mix and his supervisor addressed flow rate information during the Top Kill operation. BP announced the failure of Top Kill immediately after the operation was halted on May 29, 2010, but the May 26 message revealed that Mix understood the operation would not be successful due to the high flow rate of oil from the well.

By deleting this message in early October 2010, the government alleges that Mix was attempting to hide the fact that, during the Top Kill effort, he believed and expressed to his supervisor that the effort would not work, contrary to BP's public statements at the time.

Joan McPhee, head of Mix's legal team for the trial, argued in a May 14 filing that Mix's counsel had evidence of an exculpatory nature that conclusively demonstrate Mix's innocence in the charges against him.

"That evidence establishes affirmatively that Mix had no intent to hide either flow rate or Top Kill information and that he in fact hid neither," argued McPhee in the motion, which sought to bring a motion for a protective order to allow for immediate disclosure and use at trial of exculpatory information not currently in the government's possession.

Because the third-party privilege holder has not waived its claim of privilege, the government was unaware of this information when it indicted Mix. Mix's counsel said that a protective order that allows Mix to use the privileged information but makes clear that the privilege-holder has not waived the privilege is needed to uphold Mix's rights without causing unnecessary harm to the privilege holder.

"Indeed, the evidence establishes that, at the very same time that the government alleges Mix was 'corruptly' deleting text messages, he was being entirely forthcoming in answering questions and providing detailed information about the incident, including flow rate and Top Kill," Mix's counsel noted in the filing.


Click on the button below to add a comment.
Post a Comment
Generated by readers, the comments included herein do not reflect the views and opinions of Rigzone. All comments are subject to editorial review. Off-topic, inappropriate or insulting comments will be removed.
B. Sandul | May. 22, 2012
Poor bugger is getting the shaft thrown at him!

Michael Davis | May. 21, 2012
This is a joke. Read the sentence the government claims is key to their case: "By deleting this message in early October 2010, the government alleges that Mix was attempting to hide the fact that, during the Top Kill effort, he believed and expressed to his supervisor that the effort would not work, contrary to BPs public statements at the time." They are going after BP for operational decisions after the well had already blown out? This is as stupid as giving speeding tickets to people fleeing a tornado. America does indeed have an intelligence failure. We have smart people only when we let politics get in the picture many of us get real dumb real fast

Related Companies

Our Privacy Pledge

Deepwater Horizon Images
Distant View Deepwater Horizon (Apr 21) Subsea Dispersan Injection System Jeff Cantrell,VP Elastec/American Marine Donnie Wilson, CEO of Elastec Inc.
Donnie Wilson, CEO Elastec Inc. Deepwater Horizon in Flames (Apr 20) Dark clouds of smoke & fire emerge Macondo Oil Slick (Apr 25)
71 more images view image library

From the Career Center
Jobs that may interest you
Legal Counsel Upstream - Deep Water (Houston, TX or New Orleans, LA)
Expertise: Legal
Location: Houston, TX
Landman / Manager
Expertise: Landman
Location: Houston, TX
Contracts Administrator
Expertise: Contracts Administration
Location: Anacortes, WA
search for more jobs

Brent Crude Oil : $51.49/BBL 1.02%
Light Crude Oil : $49.04/BBL 0.59%
Natural Gas : $2.97/MMBtu 1.71%
Updated in last 24 hours